CRIMECOURTHOUSE NEWS
Justices open escape hatch for far-out criminal sentences under appellate waivers
The Supreme Court ruled 8-1 that appellate waivers in criminal cases are unenforceable if they result in a miscarriage of justice, such as when sentences involve unconstitutional factors or lack civilized procedure. The decision allows courts to override waivers in extreme cases, as seen in Munson Hunter III's case, where a judge mandated forced medication for mental health disorders as a supervised release condition.
Mentioned
Related Signal
Adjacent reporting
- Court rules defendants may under certain circumstances appeal a sentencing condition despite an appellate waiver
- Court rejects broad interpretation of compassionate release statute
- The Supreme Court’s neutering of the First Step Act
- Sydney judge overturns bail conditions limiting anti-Herzog protester from entering CBD
- Dugan attorneys argue new appeals court decision should overturn conviction
- Supreme Court dismisses bid to execute inmate with borderline intellectual disability